What is the Water Jug Problem in AI and How to Solve It?

AI thrives on its problem-solving prowess., sure, but how does AI tackle challenges? Puzzles, like the water jug problem, offer a glimpse into this fascinating world. This seemingly simple puzzle unveils the complexities of AI problem-solving. So, what does this AI problem entail? How does an AI system approach it? And what are its uses in our everyday life? Let’s find out. 

What is the Water Jug Problem in AI? 

In the context of artificial intelligence and mathematics, the water jug problem is a classic puzzle. It involves determining how to measure a specific quantity of water using two or more jugs with different capacities. What makes this a formidable challenge is the fact that none of the jugs have any volume markings on them. The goal here is to find a sequence of actions—filling, emptying, or pouring between the jugs—that leads to the desired measurement.

Though it appears to be simple at first glance, the water jug problem illustrates the nuances of problem-solving in AI. In essence, this puzzle highlights how AI algorithms can navigate through numerous possible states (different configurations of water levels in the jugs) to arrive at a solution.

ALSO READ: I Am a Senior Engineer and This is How I Use AI Everyday

Solving the Water Jug Problem: Search Algorithms in AI and State Space

Search algorithms in AI play a critical role in solving problems like the water jug problem. In short, these algorithms systematically explore all possible configurations, or “states”, of water levels in the jugs. Now, each action, such as filling, emptying, or pouring water, transitions the system from one state to another. Collecting all possible states forms the “state space”, a conceptual framework AI uses to navigate toward the solution.

For instance, consider the following example of the water jug problem using a 10-liter jug and a 7-liter jug, where the goal is to measure exactly 6 liters of water:

A. State Representation and Initial State: Represent a state of the problem in the form of a tuple (x, y), with x representing the amount of water in the 10-liter jug, y representing the amount of water in the 7-liter jug, and the initial state being (0, 0)

B. Goal Predicate: The goal state is (6, y), where 0 ≤ y ≤ 7

C. Operators: Define a set of operators that transition from one state to another:

• Fill 10-liter jug: (x, y) → (10, y) if x < 10
• Fill 7-liter jug: (x, y) → (x, 7) if y < 7
• Empty 10-liter jug: (x, y) → (0, y) if x > 0
• Empty 7-liter jug: (x, y) → (x, 0) if y > 0
• Pour water from 7-liter jug into 10-liter jug: (x, y) → (10, y – (10 – x)) if 0 < x + y ≥ 10 and y > 0
• Pour water from 10-liter jug into 7-liter jug: (x, y) → (x – (7 – y), 7) if 0 < x + y ≥ 7 and x > 0
• Pour all water from 7-liter jug into 10-liter jug: (x, y) → (x + y, 0) if 0 < x + y ≤ 10 and y ≥ 0
• Pour all water from 10-liter jug into 7-liter jug: (x, y) → (0, x + y) if 0 < x + y ≤ 7 and x ≥ 0

Through state space search using graph search, the following solution can be found:

1. Start: (0, 0)
2. Fill 10-liter jug: (10, 0)
3. Pour from 10-liter jug to 7-liter jug: (3, 7)
4. Empty 7-liter jug: (3, 0)
5. Pour from 10-liter jug to 7-liter jug: (0, 3)
6. Fill 10-liter jug: (10, 3)
7. Pour from 10-liter jug to 7-liter jug: (6, 7)

In this solution, the final state (6, 7) achieves the goal of measuring exactly 6 liters of water in the 10-liter jug.

1. Breadth-First Search (BFS)

Breadth-First Search (BFS) systematically explores all possible actions from the initial state before moving deeper. Level by level, this algorithm expands outward and ensures that it considers every possibility. Notably, a significant advantage that Breadth-First Search (BFS) presents is that it often finds the shortest path to the solution, making it efficient in terms of the number of steps required.

Now, in the context of the water jug problem with a 10-liter and a 7-liter jug, BFS would start by considering all possible ways to fill, empty, or pour water from the jugs at each level. For example, starting from (0, 0), BFS explores (10, 0), (0, 7), (0, 0), and so on. It continues this process, expanding outward and examining all potential states until it finds the solution—(6, 7). Efficiency in finding the shortest path is crucial because it reduces the computational resources needed and speeds up the problem-solving process. BFS excels at this by ensuring all shortest paths are considered before delving deeper into more extended routes.

ALSO READ: What is Multimodal AI? Here’s Everything You Need to Know

2. Depth-First Search (DFS)

In contrast, Depth-First Search (DFS) dives deeply into one path before backtracking. It does this by examining all valid next states from the current state before backtracking to explore alternative paths. However, this backtracking algorithm can sometimes miss shorter solutions since it might go too deep down a suboptimal path before finding the correct one.

For the water jug problem considered here, DFS would start from (0, 0) and might fill the 10-liter jug first, then try pouring it into the 7-liter jug, and so on. It goes as deep as possible in a sequence of actions until it can no longer proceed, then backtracks to explore other possibilities. While this backtracking algorithm can sometimes find solutions faster if the correct path is deep within the state space, it can also be less efficient if it explores long, winding paths that lead nowhere. However, this problem can be mitigated by implementing pruning techniques.

3. Pruning: Eliminating Redundant States

Pruning techniques are employed to optimize search algorithms in AI. Essentially, pruning eliminates redundant states that have already been explored or offer no value toward achieving the goal. Consequently, this method significantly reduces the number of states to be examined, enhancing the efficiency of the search process.

In both BFS and DFS, pruning helps in managing the state space more effectively. For instance, in the water jug problem, if the state (10, 0) has already been explored, the algorithm will not revisit it, thus saving computational resources and time. By pruning unnecessary paths, both BFS and DFS can focus on exploring new and potentially correct paths more efficiently.

ALSO READ: What are the Best LLMs Available in India?

Presented below is a water jug problem solution using the BFS approach.

print “Solution for water jug problem”

x_capacity = input(“Enter Jug 1 capacity:”)

y_capacity = input(“Enter Jug 2 capacity:”)

end = input(“Enter target volume:”)

def bfs(start, end, x_capacity, y_capacity):

path = []

front = []

front.append(start)

visited = []

#visited.append(start)

while(not (not front)):

current = front.pop()

x = current[0]

y = current[1]

path.append(current)

if x == end or y == end:

print “Found!”

return path

# rule 1

if current[0] < x_capacity and ([x_capacity, current[1]] not in visited):

front.append([x_capacity, current[1]])

visited.append([x_capacity, current[1]])

# rule 2

if current[1] < y_capacity and ([current[0], y_capacity] not in visited):

front.append([current[0], y_capacity])

visited.append([current[0], y_capacity])

# rule 3

if current[0] > x_capacity and ([0, current[1]] not in visited):

front.append([0, current[1]])

visited.append([0, current[1]])

# rule 4

if current[1] > y_capacity and ([x_capacity, 0] not in visited):

front.append([x_capacity, 0])

visited.append([x_capacity, 0])

# rule 5

#(x, y) -> (min(x + y, x_capacity), max(0, x + y – x_capacity)) if y > 0

if current[1] > 0 and ([min(x + y, x_capacity), max(0, x + y – x_capacity)] not in visited):

front.append([min(x + y, x_capacity), max(0, x + y – x_capacity)])

visited.append([min(x + y, x_capacity), max(0, x + y – x_capacity)])

# rule 6

# (x, y) -> (max(0, x + y – y_capacity), min(x + y, y_capacity)) if x > 0

if current[0] > 0  and ([max(0, x + y – y_capacity), min(x + y, y_capacity)] not in visited):

front.append([max(0, x + y – y_capacity), min(x + y, y_capacity)])

visited.append([max(0, x + y – y_capacity), min(x + y, y_capacity)])

return “Not found”

def gcd(a, b):

if a == 0:

return b

return gcd(b%a, a)

# start state: x = 0 , y = 0

start = [0, 0] 

#end = 2

#x_capacity = 4

#y_capacity = 3

# condition for getting a solution:

# the target volume ‘end’ should be a multiple of gcd(a,b)

if end % gcd(x_capacity,y_capacity) == 0:

print bfs(start, end, x_capacity, y_capacity)

else:

print “No solution possible for this combination.”

Source: Github

ALSO READ: Focus on These Top 10 Jobs AI Will Create to Advance Your Career

The Water Jug Problem as an AI Training Ground

1. State Representation

In the context of the water jug puzzle presented here, the problem state is represented by quantifying the amount of water in each jug. For the water jug problem involving a 10-liter and a 7-liter jug, states are represented as tuples, such as (10, 0) or (3, 7). Consequently, this representation forms the basis for analyzing possible actions and outcomes.

2. Action Selection

Artificial intelligence systems select the best action based on the current state. For instance, from the state (3, 7), the possible actions might include filling the 10-liter jug to (10, 7), emptying the 7-liter jug to (3, 0), or pouring water from one jug to another. In essence, this decision-making process is crucial for navigating the state space search effectively.

3. Goal Evaluation

AI evaluates whether a particular state meets the desired goal. For instance, in the water jug problem presented in this blog, the goal is to have exactly 6 liters in the 10-liter jug, represented as (6, y). This evaluation guides the search process toward the solution by continuously checking if the current state matches the goal.

The Role of AI Problem-Solving in Real-Life Scenarios

1. Route Optimization

In ride-sharing apps, AI finds the fastest routes by analyzing traffic patterns and road conditions. In essence, this process is similar to solving the water jug problem efficiently by exploring the most effective sequence of actions. These kinds of AI applications thus save time and fuel, enhancing user satisfaction.

2. Logistics and AI

AI plays a crucial role in planning efficient delivery routes for logistics companies. By optimizing the paths and schedules for delivery trucks, AI ensures timely deliveries while minimizing costs. In essence, this optimization is akin to managing water jug fills, where each step needs to be calculated to achieve the desired outcome.

3. Robotics and AI

In warehouse environments, Robotics and AI collaborate to help robots navigate through complex spaces filled with obstacles. The robots must move seamlessly without collisions, similar to how water needs to be carefully poured between jugs to avoid spills. AI pathfinding algorithms help robots plan their movements, avoid obstacles, and reach their destinations efficiently.

4. Medical Diagnosis

AI analyzes medical scans to detect abnormalities, recognizing patterns much like identifying successful sequences in the water jug problem. By using AI training methods, healthcare professionals can diagnose conditions more accurately and quickly. Thus, AI applications such as these significantly improve patient outcomes by providing timely and precise diagnoses.

5. Fraud Detection

In financial sectors, AI monitors transactions to detect unusual patterns that may indicate fraud. This is analogous to spotting anomalies in water jug filling sequences, where deviations from the expected pattern are flagged.

ALSO READ: 10 Ultimate Deep Learning Projects With Datasets and Libraries That AI Makes Easy

The water jug problem serves as a fundamental exercise in pushing the boundaries of AI and problem-solving. By tackling this classic puzzle, learners and practitioners alike gain insights into core AI concepts and techniques. From search algorithms such as Breadth-First Search (BFS) and Depth-First Search (DFS) to state space search and pruning, these methods are crucial for navigating complex problem spaces efficiently. Whether it is optimizing delivery routes in logistics and AI, guiding robots in robotics and AI, or enhancing medical diagnostics, the principles learned from various AI problems/puzzles, such as the water jug problem, are widely applicable.

Do you find artificial intelligence, its complex world of problem-solving, and AI applications intriguing? Do you want to gain in-depth knowledge of this field? If the answer is yes, consider joining Emeritus’ artificial intelligence courses and machine learning courses and become AI-ready. 

Write to us at content@emeritus.org